Choosing between GAF vs. BP shingles, CertainTeed, or Owens Corning? Picking between these popular brands can feel impossible. The stakes seem high, like you’re buying a car or committing to rooting for a baseball team you barely know. But if you haven’t worked with each of their products yourself, it’s hard to know which to go with.
So, which shingle should your roofing business choose for your next big job?
Which asphalt shingle brand is king?
Truth is, these products are fairly similar. There are only a few key differences to understand before you commit. You might go with any of these, depending on budget, style, and the needs of the homeowner. And your crew might like working with one product over the others.
Each of these products cost around the same, depending on where your business is and where you source your materials. But by understanding the pros and cons of each, you can offer different options or pricing levels to homeowners. The more options you can work with, the happier your customers.
So, let’s face these shingles off in the battle of the century. Here’s your breakdown of each option, with pro/con summaries at the end if you’re short on time.
GAF vs. BP vs. CertainTeed vs. Owens Corning
Who wins the battle royale?
The above chart is a good starting point, but it doesn’t reveal a clear winner. Each option has its strengths and weaknesses. You may even want to change it up for each roof you do.
So, what’s most important for the job at hand? Warranties, wind limits, algae protection, ease of installation, or aesthetics?
GAF Timberline HDZ
- Decent durability
- Great warranties
- Advanced installation features
GAF Timberlines are common, so most roofers already have an opinion on whether they like Timberline. GAF’s warranty options and support service are among the best, so it’s a solid choice for those starting out.
BP Mystique
- Wins on wind resistance rating
- Offers a unique earth-tone look
- Simple, traditional installation
If the homeowner wants a certain style, BP may be the way to go. Keep in mind, BP doesn’t offer any specific fastening technology. It’s simple, straightforward, with no fancy gimmicks.
When it comes to GAF vs. BP shingles, GAF has better algae protection, but BP has a more distinct look which you might prefer.
CertainTeed Landmark
- Quality shingle
- 25-year algae protection
- Wide nailing area for easier installation
If you use CertainTeed start and hip and ridge products, you also get an improved wind warranty (from 110 to 130 mph).
GAF Timberline vs. CertainTeed Landmark are similar on paper. It’ll come down to your brand and installation preference here.
Owens Corning Duration
- Come in bold colors
- Easy to install
- Offer nice wind protection
Owens Corning Duration shingles are a well-rounded choice with their own special look and feel. If you want a mix of quality, installation, and modern style, these might be the way to go.
If you’re thinking GAF Timberline vs. Owens Corning Duration, GAF has a better algae warranty. Owens Corning has bolder colors. If you aren’t too concerned about algae, take your pick.
The final word on shingles
These products are very comparable with a few distinct, specific differences. It comes down to visuals, your installation preference, availability, and budget.
Use the above guide as a reference point. But it’s best to try each product out and make your own judgement on which option is best for the types of roofs you work on. Nobody knows your work better than you!
While you’re here, check out Roofr’s material order automations.
Save time and hassle by turning proposals into instant material orders. Plus, link your Roofr account right to QXO, ABC, or SRS for accurate availability and pricing info. Take a look! Your future self will thank you.